March 3, 2010 0

Weekly Comic Shopping List 3/3/10

By Scott Cederlund in comics
16553.jpg14414_400x600.jpg69302comic_storystory_full-1086399..jpg

A blessedly small week, finally. 

  • Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 8 Vol 6 Retreat TP–  I'm hoping this series picks up the pace a bit.  Honestly, I can't remember what's happened in any of the volumes past a giant Dawn rampaging through the streets of Tokyo, which I think was actually in the 4th trade.  What did happen in the fifth trade?  I'd like to know.
  • Sweet Tooth #7– The last page of Sweet Tooth #6 was absolutely wrenching and it looks like #7 picks up that emotion, capturing the tone that Lemire perfected in his Essex County books.  If you asked me to name my favorite books of the moment, I have the feeling that I would overlook Sweet Tooth but each and every issue is just such a gut punch that I think I want to forget it as much as possible.  But here it is, another Wednesday, and I'm waiting for my gut punch.  Thanks, Lemire.
  • Girl Comics#1– Anthologies aren't doing much for me right now.  They're filled with some fantastic stories, some crappy stories and some middle of the road stories.  But this one looks like a lot of fun.

Posted via email from Wednesdays Haul’s posterous

Similar Posts


March 2, 2010 1

Review: The Flash Rebirth #6

By Scott Cederlund in comics

?I’m trying to figure out what’s different now; what have we learned about Barry Allen during The Flash: Rebirth?   The answer is kind of surprising, at least to me.  We’ve learned that you can kill Barry’s mom but don’t touch Iris.  We’ve learned that it’s o.k. to Barry if the world thinks his father is a killer just as long as Barry knows the truth.  And we’ve learned that Barry’s big offensive maneuver is to shove his enemies in the back.  For those few lessons, Geoff Johns and Ethan Van Sciver wasted our time for six issues while they attempted to make us accept and care Barry Allen again.


In The Flash: Rebirth #6, the last issue of Geoff Johns and Ethan Van Sciver’s latest miniseries breathing new life back into old characters, Barry Allen races to beat his nemesis Professor Zoom back to the past where Zoom plans to kill Barry’s wife Iris.  They run and they run.  They occasionally catch glimpses of their past.  They almost throw punches but then they run a bit more.  And then the stories is over.  The Flash pulls out his big move and pushes Zoom into a giant test tube.  Oh, and there’s a parade, a Flash parade.  We can’t forget about the parade, or the JLA party.  The JLA throw a party for the Flash, with a cake and a “welcome back” banner.  And that’s it.  That’s the end of the miniseries.

When Johns and Van Sciver produced Green Lantern: Rebirth a few years ago, it was easy to understand the purpose of that book; to redeem Hal Jordan and make him a hero again.  Jordan was one of those classic characters who was really maligned during the 90s, the decade which took a hero and made him into a killer.  The character needed a symbolic as well as a literal rebirth, which is exactly what Johns and Van Sciver did for Hal Jordan.  They brought him back and they brought him back as a hero.  Tackling Barry Allen is an altogether different creature altogether; Barry didn’t need redemption.  Our last memories of him are racing around the Anti-Monitor’s machine, racing to his death even as he saved the universe.  Barry died a hero.  Without any part of Barry’s character or history needing to be tweaked and even forgotten, like Hal’s murderous rampage, there’s no drive or force behind The Flash: Rebirth.  And without a need for a tweak, there’s no exploration of Barry, any of the Flashes or the Speed Force.  Simply, there’s nothing behind The Flash: Rebirth unless you like to watch characters run and then run some more.

If you’re not going to explore the hero, then you need to make the villain a true and unique threat.  Well, Zoom is essentially the anti-Flash, right down the an opposite-colored version of Flash’s costume.  Zoom lacks any dimension or motivation other than a hatred of Barry Allen.  One of the great things that Geoff Johns did on his original run on The Flash was fleshing out Flash’s rogue gallery, reestablishing their group as a unique group among villains.  They had a code of ethics and even a swagger that you just generally didn’t see among other villains.  Zoom lacks any of their depth; he might as well be a mustache twirler who has Iris tied up on the tracks as the train fast approaches. 

It’s no major spoiler to say that, at the end of the issue, the bad guy is defeated and the heroes celebrate.  A party is thrown, cake is served and everyone’s happy.  Barry Allen is back.  Iris is safe and the world still thinks that Barry’s dad killed his mom, which just strikes me as an incredibly odd plot point to be introduced in this miniseries without providing a satisfactory ending to the murder mystery but that’s really how this whole series could be described; one give plot contrivance without any satisfactory ending or resolution.  Barry’s back but why should we care?  Sadly, this final issue gives us little reason to.

The Flash: Rebirth #6
Written by: Geoff Johns
Pencilled by: Ethan Van Sciver
Inked by: Ethan Van Sciver & Scott Hanna
Lettered by: Rob Leigh
Colored by: Brian Miller

Similar Posts


February 26, 2010 0

Weekend Reading– Beans and Dreams

By Scott Cederlund in comics
15805.jpg1717_400x600.jpg12537_400x600.jpg

Driving in to work this morning, I was listening to Wood and Vince on the 11 O'Clock Comics podcast talk about Beanworld.  This made me both happy and sad.  I was happy to hear them talk about Larry Marder's fantastic comic but sad that I've had Dark Horse's three hardcovers sitting on a shelf and haven't been able to get to read through them yet.  I've read a lot of Beanworld but it's been while since I last dived into the series.  I really want to try and find a chunk of time to sit down and go through all three of the books, immersing myself in Marder's world.

The other night, I got to see Neil Gaiman do a reading out in Naperville.  While there, I picked up a copy of P.Craig Russell's adaptation of The Dream Hunters.  For some reason when it was coming out as a comic, Russell's version of this story, originally a novella illlustrated by Yoshika Amano, just didn't click with me.  But looking through this collection, I'm just completely in awe of Russell's lyrical style.  I just love his artwork and it looks fantastic in this book. 

Posted via email from Wednesdays Haul’s posterous

Similar Posts


February 24, 2010 0

Review: Joe The Barbarian #2

By Scott Cederlund in comics

A giant, armor wearing, warrior, white rat. Who saw that one coming?


You know it’s bad in Joe the Barbarian #2 when Captain Jean Luc Picard is giving up the battle; when he’s passing off his phaser to some boy and then hobbling off to whatever final fate awaits him. We’re talking about the captain of the Enterprise here. He’s faced Klingons and Borg without ever breaking a sweat but his latest adversary is just too much for him. He’s already lost a leg. What more can we ask of the man? But then you realize as you’re reading the book, this isn’t Picard. It’s not even actor Patrick Stewart making a surprising cameo in this story. It’s a toy, a 3″ action figure, still just as defeated, handing his tiny little toy gun over to diabetic, and possibly hallucinating, Joe.


This second issue of Grant Morrison and Sean Murphy’s miniseries continues to explore a toy world that is at war. The Picard figure, missing its lower leg, is only one of the casualties of this war. In a stunning 2-page spread, Murphy shows us all sort of childhood toys and memories under assult by the forces of King Death, a villain who so far remains unseen. You can never really forget that we’re looking at childhood toys but Murphy makes the figures so lively and expressive that they become as real as Joe is. There’s no difference between Joe’s anguish at not understanding what’s going on and the torture of some plastic toys at the bad guy’s hands. The stuffed animals, huddled together in fear, are no less real because they have stuffing in them.


Morrison and Murphy play off this uncertainty of reality and fiction; Joe’s house is no less dangerous for him than the imaginary land of his toys. Even Joe’s pet white rat Jack becomes an armored warrior in Joe’s other world, captured during the battles with Lord Death. Whether it’s a quest to bring back “the throne of light” or to get his glucose tablet, Joe is in a lot of trouble.


While covering familiar ground for him, it feels like Morrison is approaching writing Joe The Barbarian completely differently than he usually does. Like his We3, the writing this issue is stripped down and uncluttered. He leaves the reader to fill in a lot of the subtext while he concentrates on telling a strong story with his artist. Sean Murphy actually fills in a lot of that subtext and symbolism in this book. Joe the Barbarian #2 is a much simpler story, without being simplistic.


Joe the Barbarian #2

“Chapter 2: Cloud Quay to Feather Forest Falls”

Written by: Grant Morrison

Drawn by: Sean Murphy

Colored by: Dave Stewart

Lettered by: Todd Klein



Similar Posts


February 23, 2010 1

Review– Dark Avengers Volume 2: Molecule Man

By Scott Cederlund in comics

Do you remember what Brian Michael Bendis’ first major act as the Avengers’ writer was?


He blew up Avenger’s mansion.


Sure, it’s been blown up before but he annhilated it in Avengers: Disassembled, using the Vision and a quinjet to blast it to kingdom come even after he killed Jack of Hearts (the character’s second death in about a year) and the second Ant Man.  And that was just the start of Bendis’ deconstruction of the Avengers which continued for over five years and has culminated in Dark Avengers, the book featuring an Avengers team made up of killers, psychopaths and Norman Osborn.


In Dark Avengers Volume 2: The Molecule Man, Bendis continues to use two previously ill defined characters, Osborn and The Sentry, to create a fascinating look at the two characters who probably best exemplify the current state of chaos and uncertainty that is the Avengers.  Both characters in this book are struggling for control over themselves and others.  Norman’s own inner demons (and even a few of his external ones) pull at him, almost making you feel something other than hate for this character.  The Sentry, a character who it seemed that even Bendis couldn’t make interesting, becomes a truly frightening wildcats in Osborn’s plan, unable to be controled or killed.


The thing that Bendis has given these Dark Avengers are threats worthy of any Avengers team; certainly more worthy of the Avengers’ attention than the Hood over in New Avengers is.  The first volume of Dark Avengers showed the team facing Doctor Doom, Morgana Le Fey and Atlantean terrorists.  In this new book, Bendis has them facing the Molecule Man, a somewhat forgotten villain whose career highlight is probably Marvel’s Secret Wars.  The Molecule Man is an apt opponent, particularly for Osborn and the Sentry, as his own trials and struggles are mirror images of the Dark Avengers’ personal dilemmas.  Armed with uncontrollable and possibly limitless powers, the Molecule Man is constantly assailed by voices inside his head, which manifest in the forms of the Beyonder, the Enchantress, Dormamu and Mephisto, all creatures of deception.  Just like Molecule Man, Osborn is shown in the book at the mercy of his own inner demons and goblins.  The man is not nearly as in control as he wants to be.


The Sentry has been Bendis’ own personal obsession for a couple of years now, a character he has been struggling to make as important in his audience eyes as he is in the writer’s own eyes.  By putting him under the sway of Osborn, Bendis is able to show the inner turmoil of the character without always having him break down into tears.  There are times, perfectly drawn by Mike Deodato, that the character finally looks like a true superman, full of confidence, control and power.  At those times though, he also looks like a terrible god, devoid of any humanity or compassion.  Finally after years of moping around, the Sentry is finally gaining some self insight and unlocking his true capabilities and power.

Maybe it’s the shelf life of Dark Avengers is set to expire soon that’s forcing Bendis to concentrate on the characters in this title.  Beside Osborn and the Sentry, Ares and Victoria Hand also get strong stories in this book.  Ares has to face up to the fact that his son is working for/being trained by Nick Fury, a man whom Ares should consider an outlaw and an enemy.  Bendis forces Ares to face up to certain questions about fatherhood that give the character more to do than stand around and swing his battle ax.  Victoria Hand, who started out as a third rate Maria Hill knockoff (and that’s pretty low in and of itself,) is put into positions of power and responsibility that she’s woefully unsuited for.  But Bendis gets to the hearts of each of their stories very quickly.  He doesn’t spend countless pages and issues building up to something; he has these events happen in the characters’ lives and has them address them immediately.  That’s the difference between giving Bendis 60 issues and only 12. With the impending Siege and Heroic Age that’s set to follow, Bendis does not have the time to meander with these character’s stories like he did with Spider Woman or Luke Cage over in New or Mighty Avengers.

As Marvel primes the pump for Siege, Dark Avengers is the book that ultimately defines the spirit of the last 6 years; it’s the culmination of deconstruction of the Avengers and the vacuum that’s left in its place.  The Avengers gave way to the New Avengers, the Young Avengers, the Mighty Avengers, the Pet Avengers, the Illuminati, the Cabal and now to the Dark Avengers.  As Bendis has written the New Avengers, they’ve been caught at the heart of this deconstruction, trying to rebuild but trapped in a cycle of wars and invasions that never give them the chance to rebuild what the Avengers had been.  While the Mighty Avengers and even the Young Avengers have acted as stop gaps, it’s Bendis’ Dark Avengers that rise up to fill in the void left behind by Captain America, Iron Man and Thor.  You’ve got two of those three archetypes alone in Norman Osborn and both the Sentry and Ares provide double the god power for Thor’s absence.  For these “lost” years of the Avengers, the Dark Avengers are the rock bottom.

The other consistent strength of Dark Avengers (let’s ignore Matt Fraction’s “Utopia” issues for the time being) is Mike Deodato and the wonderful art that he’s turning in on this book.  Dark Avengers has been a fantastic showcase of his work, showing a shadowy and dark side to classic superheroics.  His Avengers are almost pure John Buscema, drawn at a classic 8 heads tall with barrel chests, just like Buscema taught us all in How to Draw Comics the Marvel Way.  Deodato’s artwork feels simultaneously classic and new, showing us the modern gods and goddesses that walk around in Avenger comics.

Dark Avengers Volume 2: Molecule Man is almost the end; it’s the penultimate adventure of Osborn’s Avengers but it’s also the end of Bendis’ complete destruction of the Avengers.  He began his grand Avenger story blowing up the venerable mansion but that’s nothing compared to calling Bullseye, Venom and the Green Goblin Avengers.  With Siege and the end finally in sight, Bendis turns in some of his tightest and best stories of this era of Avengers, beautifully drawn by Deodato. 

Dark Avengers: Vol 2.: Molecule Man
Written by: Brian Michael Bendis
Drawn by: Mike Deodato (additional art by Greg Horn)
Colored by: Rain Beredo
Lettered by: VC’s Cory Petit

Dark Avengers, Vol. 2: Molecule Man is available on Amazon.com.

Similar Posts


February 22, 2010 0

Random Quote: Martin Scorsese on Criticism

By Scott Cederlund in random quote

“It’s not important if a critic ‘like’ or ‘doesn’t like’ a movie.  What is important is that he engages with it fully, brings to his responses the conviction, the passion, that the director brings to the films’ making.  Opinion is evanescent, but the work abides.”

Martin Scorsese in the introduction to SCORSESE BY EBERT.

Similar Posts


February 22, 2010 0

Weekly Comic Shopping List 2/24/10

By Scott Cederlund in comics
14017_400x600.jpg71638comic_storystory_full-5816848..jpg51Au2es2vKL.jpg


  • Blackest Night #7
  • Flash Rebirth #6 — Two awaited Geoff Johns books this week.  It's been so long, I don't know if I really care to wait to see the end of Flash Rebirth but I've got the first 5 so what's one more?  This relaunch has had some cool moments but feels like it's been a narrative black hole, treading ground until we could get to an actual series, which looks to finally be starting in a month or two.  Blackest Night continues to chug along with this penultimate issue.  Both of these series illustrates the strengths and weaknesses of Johns as a writer– he comes up with some cool ideas but they often come across as he's playing with his favorite toys.
  • Mighty Avengers Vol 6 Unspoken HC
  • New Avengers Vol 12 Power Loss HC– After last week's Dark Avengers V2, we're getting three Avengers collections in 2 weeks, which I think pretty much catch us up on the Civil War/Secret Invasion/Seige era Avengers.  I'm working on a Dark Avengers review that begins to draw together some of my thoughts and theories on the last 5 years of Avengers' stories.  That review should be up in the next day or two.  If all goes to plan, I should be reviewing both of these trades next week.
  • Naoki Urasawas 20th Century Boys Vol 7 TP– Pretty soon, this will be the only Urasawa book we see unless someone has already snapped up the rights to Billy Bat that we don't know about.  I've still got to finish V8, so I think both of them will be next week's "Weekend Reading." 

Posted via email from Wednesdays Haul’s posterous

Similar Posts


February 19, 2010 0

Weekend Reading

By Scott Cederlund in comics
13871_180x270.jpg9781934287736.jpg

Matt Wagner and Osamu Tezuka.  I can think of worst ways to spend the weekend.

Posted via email from Wednesdays Haul’s posterous

Similar Posts


February 17, 2010 0

Weekly Comic Shopping List 2/17/10

By Scott Cederlund in comics

  • Star Wars Legacy Vol 8 Tatooine TP–  I think I’ve come to love the characters in SW Legacy more than any character in the prequel movies and possibly even more than the characters in the original movies.  Ostrander and Duursema have created a whole social and political world that builds on Lucas’ foundation but add color and depth that rarely exists on the screen.  For my money, this series is probably better than any sequel trilogy that Lucas could put together.

  • Kobra Resurrection TP– Finally, the end of Checkmate gets collected, as well as some other Kobra stuff.  The Ivan Brandon Kobra story included is also supposed to be pretty good.

  • Starman Omnibus Vol 4 HC– The first three volumes of this series have been soooooo nice and I can’t wait to have the entire series collected some day– emphasis on “entire.” 

  • Joe The Barbarian #2– After reading The Filth and Flex Mentallo over the past couple of weeks, I want to see if this is going to go where I think it could and if this turns out to be part of an unofficial Morrison trilogy.  Ever since Animal Man’s “I can see you” moment, fiction and reality have collided in Morrison’s story and fiction always wins out one way or another as it seeps into Morrison’s idea of reality. 

  • Ignition City Vol 1 TP– No Hero kind of soured me on Warren Ellis, at least for the moment but I want to check this one out and see if it’s as wonderful and original as his Freak Angels is.

  • Almost Silent–  Ah, more from Norwegian cartoonist Jason. It’ll surely feature crow-like people doing absurd things, all in the name of fortune and art.  And it’ll probably be good too. 

Posted via email from Wednesdays Haul’s posterous

Similar Posts


February 16, 2010 0

Review- Phonogram: The Singles Club #7

By Scott Cederlund in comics

The best pop albums always have a killer last song, the perfect track to end an album while leaving you wanting more. That’s what Kieron Gillen and Jamie McKelvie do with Phonogram: The Singles Club #7; they deliver the perfect single to their series.

In Phonogram: The Singles Club, Kieron Gillen and Jamie McKelvie have shown us a number of characters during a night of music and magic, each with their own issues and personal hangups. Almost no one who has highlighted during the series is who they want to be. From the club DJ Seth who wants to be in more control than he really is to queen bitch Emily Aster, who sees her true self every time she looks in the mirror, they all want to be someone or with someone different than they are. That’s why David Kohl, the “hero” of the first Phonogram series Rue Brittania, is only a supporting character here; we know Kohl and he’s perfectly happy with who he is. In the seventh and final issue of The Singles Club, Gillen and McKelvie make Kid With Knife, who at best is Kohl’s sidekick and at worst his flunky, the main character. Like Kohl, KWK knows who and what he is. He isn’t a phonomancer (a music-based magician) but he doesn’t need to be. After Kohl tries to explain to KWK how to listen to a song to harness it’s power, how to focus on the song and to let it possess you, KWK laughs off the instruction. “That’s magic?” he wonders. “Hell, everybody does that.” And just like that, KWK puts every other pretender and wannabe character in this series in their place, showing that they’re hardly as special as they wished they were.

For the rest of KWK’s story, Gillen and McKelvie wordlessly follow him as he does what everyone does when driven by the music; he tries to pick up a couple of girls, gets into a fight and gets chased through the streets, goes to the club, dances and finally does get to take a girl home at the end of the night. Maybe for a phonomancer, it’s a night of magic but for KWK, you get the feeling it’s just a night like any other, magic or not. In the other issues of this series, Gillen has tried to show the characters using their “magic” to make a better night or even a better life for themselves. But, in the end, all of their effort usually produced nothing other than the realization that maybe their magic wasn’t strong enough. For KWK, the night is not about the magic but it is about the night and what kind of trouble a boy could get into with just enough power and self awareness. The magic that Kohl teaches KWK means nothing. It’s just the same thing that he does every night. It may be magic or it may not be. It not nearly as important as who you are and what you do.

McKelvie and colorist Matthew Wilson create the rhythm this issue as they bring Gillen’s mostly wordless script to life. McKelvie tells the story through his characters faces and body language. It’s been a strength he’s shown often during this miniseries but it’s crucial here as he’s creating for us Gillen’s story. McKelvie has to show us what the characters are doing and even what they’re saying to one another in this story, occasionally relying on hilarious pictograms to substitute as actual dialogue. As well as delivering the story, McKelvie and Wilson create a buzz in this book. KWK is buzzing throughout the issue and it’s contagious to the reader as the storytelling in this issue creates a sound all its own. It’s not a sound of words and voices but a sound of color and of an unheard music. This issue is that perfect instrumental piece that closes out a great pop album. The singer (or maybe the writer in this instance) takes a break and the musicians (or in this case, the artist and colorist) take center stage and just create a whole new experience solely with their instruments. As Gillen tells us in the backmatter of this issue, “sometimes actions do speak louder than words.” If that’s true, this is one loud comic.

Gillen gets his shot as well with four short stories in the end, illustrated by Nikki Cook, Becky Cloonan, Andy Bloor and Sean Azzopardi. All of these short stories during this series have been nice little character pieces, such as when David Kohl tries to explain The Talking Head’s “Once in a Lifetime” lyrics to some unsuspecting party goer. Built around music or dancing, these stories show how so much of our lives are either explicitly or tangentially tied to music. They’re fun b-sides to Gillen and McKelvie’s singles.

Phonogram: The Singles Club #7

“Wolf Like Me”

Written by: Keiron Gillen

Drawn & Lettered by: Jamie McKelvie (art assistance by: Julia Scheele)

Colored by: Matthew Wilson

“The Queen is Dead”

Drawn by: Nikki Cook

“Blood Mountain”

Drawn by: Becky Cloonan

“30″

Drawn by: Andy Bloor

“Once In A Lifetime”

Drawn by: Sean Azzopardi

Posted via email from Wednesdays Haul’s posterous

Similar Posts